Review: Remember When by Judith McNaught

Posted July 24, 2008 by Holly in Reviews | 5 Comments

Review: Remember When by Judith McNaughtReviewer: Holly
Remember When by Judith McNaught

Publication Date: October 1st 1997
Genres: Fiction
Pages: 432
Add It: Goodreads
Amazon | Barnes & Noble | The Ripped Bodice | Google Play Books

Remember When is one of Judith McNaught's most enchanting New York Times bestsellers, "a tender novel celebrating the power of love" (The Literary Times).

Alone on a moonlit balcony at Houston's White Orchid Charity Ball, Diana Foster courageously upheld the sparkling image of her family's Beautiful Living magazine. Recently jilted by her fiancé for an Italian heiress -- an insult delivered via a sleazy tabloid -- Diana was now very publicly unengaged, and surrounded by humiliating rumors. So why was billionaire Cole Harrison closing in on her with two crystal flutes and a bottle of champagne?

The former stableboy had received an ultimatum from his uncle: bring home a wife -- soon -- or lose his share of a booming multinational business. Coolly analytical and arrestingly attractive, Cole knew what he wanted in a bride, and Diana Foster -- rich, beautiful, principled -- fit the role perfectly. But while a long, slow kiss sealed the bargain that solved both their dilemmas, neither imagined the extraordinary journey that would begin on that unforgettable night. . . .


One of the things Judith McNaught does better than anyone is write drama. Her novels are filled with conflicts. The h/h are always struggling with each other, outside influences and themselves. And just when you think all is well and things are resolved and they’re going to live happily ever after, some new drama occurs and BAM, they’re back at square one. Remember When is one of the few McNaught novels where the drama is at a minimum and the h/h work together.

Unfortunately, I think the love story here gets buried under a lot of technical jargon and too much back story. The first 7 or so chapters focuses on when Cole and Diana first teenagers. Cole was a poor college student who was working in the stable of a wealthy family to support himself. Diana was friends with the stable owner’s daughter and met Cole that way. They became friends and ended up spending quite a bit of time together. But Diana – along with all her friends and then some – had a major crush on Cole. They (she and her friends) used to make bets about who would be the first to kiss him. Although it was cute to read about their past together, I feel it went on for too long. I’d rather have learned about it during the present, or shortened the amount of time JM spent on the past. Although some of what happened then is necessary to the story in present day, I think a few chapters at most would have been enough.

The other problem is the outside conflict Cole and Diana have to face takes center stage here. Diana and Cole and their relationship play second fiddle. Diana’s company is suffering because she’s just been dumped by her fiance for a 19 year old bimbo. Cole’s public image is crap and his uncle decides to blackmail him into getting married and providing grandchildren. He proposes to Diana, thinking they can help each other out, but things get complicated when he realizes he cares for her and vice verse. The problem is that Cole has made a lot of enemies and now he’s under investigation by SEC for having inside information on trades (or something..I’m blanking out right now, sorry!).

McNaught spends a lot of time on the business aspects – both Diana and Cole’s. While I found it interesting, I feel it took away from their relationship too much. I would have liked to see more page time w/ just them. Still, I love that they stuck by each other. Once they committed to each other, that was it. Fabulous stuff. I also loved seeing Cole lighten up with Diana’s help. One of my favorite parts of the book is when she gives him a new tie and he keeps bringing it up. It was cute.

Overall the relationship aspects of the story are wonderful, but overshadowed. I’d recommend it just for Diana and Cole.

H/H: 4.5 out of 5
The rest: 3.5 out of 5

This book is available from Simon & Schuster. You can buy it here.


Tagged: , , , , , ,

5 responses to “Review: Remember When by Judith McNaught

  1. I’ve read PARADISE and PERFECT of Judith’s McNaughts and really enjoyed those two. They were romance suspense, I haven’t read any of her historicals yet I wouldn’t know where to start! LOL. But I was recommended to start those of her contemps and thrilled I did. I believe I do have REMEMBER WHEN in my TBR, but I know I want to get a recommendation of which historical to read of hers.

  2. tabitha

    Caffey, if I remember correctly – ‘Something Wonderful’, ‘Almost Heaven’, and ‘Once and Always’ are historicals of JM. You will enjoy those three (I did, anyway). As for ‘Remember When’, I didn’t enjoy it b/c of the ouside conflicts. I’ve re-read many of JM books but RW is not one of them, unfortunately.

  3. I like this one, but you’re right, Holly, there was a lot of the business aspect. One thing also, I wish Ms McNaught didn’t spend that much time on when they were young. Still a highly enjoyable book though 🙂

  4. Anonymous

    This is nothing new since I’ve made many post during JM month but I have nothing bad to say about this book. This is my brain’s favorite book – everything has has a reason for being. The business part played out well- not something authors use as backdrop and then gloss over with a ta-da solution.

    Perhaps it isn’t as dramatic as her other books but it’s refreshing after re-reading Whitney, My Love and Perfect. My brain hates those while my heart just go all sappy and giddy.


  5. Lori

    Although it’s been a while since I read this one, I do remember reaelly enjoying the back story of their teen years. But I do agree with you about the businss stuff. I remember shaking my head thinking it was a little ’80s’ cliched. But still a great book.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.