DIK Reading Challenge Review: The Secret Pearl by Mary Balogh

Posted January 27, 2010 by Tracy in Reviews | 12 Comments

The Secret Pearl by Mary Balogh

He first spies her in the shadows outside a London theatre, a ravishing creature forced to barter her body to survive.

To the woman known simply as Fleur, the well-dressed gentleman with the mesmerizing eyes is an unlikely savior. And when she takes the stranger to her bed, she never expects to see him again. But then Fleur accepts a position as governess to a young girl…and is stunned to discover that her midnight lover is a powerful nobleman. As two wary hearts ignite–and the threat of scandal hovers over them–one question remains: will she be mistress or wife?

Fleur is on the run. She’s accidentally killed a man and has run to London to escape her fate. With no references and eventually no food she does the only thing she feels she can – she sells her body. Her first client ends up being the Duke of Ridgeway. He is married and this is the only time he’s ever cheated on his wife. He ends up being angry at what he is doing and takes Fleur is rough manner. Fleur doesn’t go back on the streets when she recovers but tries the employment agency one more time. She ends up finding employment as a governess and moves into a grand home in Doresetshire. Of course the home is the home of the Duke and Duchess of Ridgeway.

The Duchess is none too thrilled at having Fleur as governess but deals with it. When the Duke comes back from London the Duchess believes that the Duke has hired Fleur because she is his doxie. Fleur is shocked to see the awful, scarred man who took her virginity so horribly and is terribly scared of him. Despite her fear, however, she starts to see that he’s not a bad person at all and cares deeply about people. She also comes to care deeply about her charge, Lady Pamela.

The Duke likes having Fleur as his daughter Pamela’s governess. He enjoys listening to her give Pamela lessons. He tells himself that it’s all for Pamela, but is it really? He doesn’t want to admit that he’s starting to have feelings for Fleur – but he is committed in his relationship with his wife. His wife however wants nothing to do with him, is revolted by him and his scarred face and hates him with everything she is. In fact so much so that they have never consummated their marriage. How, you may ask, could Pamela be his daughter then? Well, you see – Pamela is actually his brother’s child but the Duke claims her as his own.

When Fleur’s guardian, Matthew, finds Fleur at the Duke’s residence he tries to blackmail her into marriage – which is what he was trying to do when she fled her real home originally. The Duke discovers what’s happening and helps Fleur – but there is so much more behind the story.

I’m discovering that I really like Mary Balogh’s writing. Although I’ve only read 2 of her books they’ve been told beautifully and they really pull me into the different settings. The ones I’ve read have not been simple stories at all, but intricate tales of love. The problems that I had with the book really didn’t have anything to do with the writing or the story itself but more my own issues with infidelity in books. I don’t like it. Usually when I see a book where I know there will be cheating I just don’t read it. But when Jenre, who has this book on her DIK list, gave us a blurb of the book I got intrigued.

This was a very different type of book with infidelity in it. The Duke of Ridgeway, Adam Kent, had gone off in the infantry and comes home after a year of being thought dead. His half brother had assumed the position of Duke and was betrothed to Adam’s once fiance, Sybil. The half brother takes off and leaves Sybil pregnant. She accepts Adam’s proposal of marriage and Adam accepts the child as his own. But as I said, Sybil hates Adam because she is with Adam and not Thomas, his brother, and she believes that Adam has sent Thomas away. Adam doesn’t love his wife but he is determined not to screw things up – unfortunately Fleur’s presence in his home more or less undermines that. Fleur and Adam know that they can’t be together – and it takes quite a long time for her to see the wonderful person that Adam is, but they can’t stop loving each other.

This was a very good book with a lot going on. I did have times while reading when I was saying – no, don’t do that (with regard to Adam and Fleur) but it was a beautiful love story – despite the infidelity issues.

Rating: 4 out of 5


Tagged: , ,

12 responses to “DIK Reading Challenge Review: The Secret Pearl by Mary Balogh

  1. Oh my, this is my favourite Mary Balogh book to date and my first Mary Balogh book, period. I adored it. I can understand the issues with infidelity, but I found myself more sympathetic once you find out exactly what Adam's had to put up with and how much he's done already.

  2. AJ – I really did like the book and I realize with historicals they just couldn't get a divorce. But Adam was so determined to commit himself to his marriage and daughter but then there was Fleur. He was horribly tortured emotionally and it did make me like him all the more because he was so conflicted. If he had been nonchalant about the whole thing I probably wouldn’t have liked him at all.

  3. Tracy, this is my very favorite Mary Balogh book. It has some incredibly beautiful scenes/passages in it. I thought Balogh did a terrific job of developing this story and the characters, especially Adam. I'm so glad you enjoyed it. 🙂

  4. You know I have never read Mary Balogh I hear so many good things about her and I love historicals! Which would you suggest I read? Is this the one I should pick up?

  5. Hilcia – You're right – it's a great book. Its beauty is what made the book for me.

    Chris – pffft

    Sarai – this is a great book and if you have no issues with infidelity then this might be a wonderful one to start with. The other one I read was Slightly Dangerous. Yes it was in the middle of a series but I didn't feel like I needed to read the others first. The hero in that one was very emotionally closed off but was brought out by the heroine. I loved that one.

  6. I've never read a Mary Balogh book, but after reading your review…I think I will give this one a try. It's sounds interesting! Thanks…;)

  7. Lovely review Tracy. This is a Balogh I haven't read yet, it's on the tbr pile. I love her writing and look forward to reading this. Thanks for the review. 🙂

  8. Maija – I did enjoy it. Hope you like it as much when you re-read. 🙂

    Jessica – As I said I've only read 2 of her books but they were lovely.

    Leslie – You're welcome, and thank YOU, that's very nice. Now dig it out of the TBR! lol

  9. I loved this book! It was dark but…the characters drew me in. And I'm not really a fan of infidelity stories either.

    I also like Slightly Dangerous!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.