Reviewer: Holly Can't Stand The Heat by Louisa Edwards
Series: Recipe for Love #1
Publisher: Macmillan
Publication Date: September 1st 2009
Genres: Fiction
Pages: 368
Add It: Goodreads
Amazon | Barnes & Noble | The Ripped Bodice | Google Play Books
Series Rating:
For sharp-tongued food critic Miranda Wake, the chance to spend a month in Adam Temple's kitchen to write an exposé is a journalistic dream come true. Surely Miranda can find a way to cut the hotshot chef down to size once she learns what really goes on at his trendy Manhattan restaurant. But she never expected Adam to find out her most embarrassing secret: she has no idea how to cook.
Adam's not about to have his reputation burned by a critic who doesn't even know the difference between poaching and paring. He'll just have to give the tempting redhead a few private lessons of his own—teaching her what it means to cook with passion...and doing more with his hands than simply preparing sumptuous food.
*****As part of our 10 year anniversary celebration, we’ll be re-posting old reviews that make us cringe, laugh or sigh all over again.
WARNING: This review contains a major rant about the heroine. It will contain strong language and spoilers for the story. Read on at your own risk.
I’ve mentioned before that I generally have a dislike for heroines who are journalists. I’ve made some exceptions, but generally I try to stay away from novels featuring them, because I know I have a personal bias and I don’t want that to color my reading experience. I chose to pick this one up anyway because Miranda Wake is a food critic, rather than an investigative journalist (the type I generally have the biggest issues with). Also? It’s a foodie book and I’m a huge foodie.
I went into this expecting one thing, and got something else entirely.
Miranda Wake is a bitter food critic who desperately wants a book deal. On the pre-opening night of a new restaurant, Market, she gets blitzed and has it out with the Exec Chef and Owner, Adam Temple. She hasn’t even had his food yet, but she’s already spouting off about how he’s pretentious and his food sucks. So he challenges her to spend just one night in his kitchen, thinking to shut her up. Only she accepts.
Then his investor gets together with her editor and they decide she’ll stay for a month. Which is when she gets a book deal; she’s to write a book “dishing” about Adam Temple and what really goes on in his kitchen. While Miranda is busy digging up dirt on Adam and the entire staff, she finds herself falling in love with him. Which I completely understood, because I adored Adam.
He was sweet and adorable, with a strong sense of right and wrong. He was probably the best part about this book. I loved that even though he had preconceived notions about Miranda he set them aside and judged her on his own observations. I loved that he was tough but fair in the kitchen. I loved that he hired chefs based on their merits as cooks, rather than their diplomas or schooling. He had a somewhat gruff exterior, but inside he was kind and loving.
I absolutely adored the secondary characters. The entire kitchen staff came alive for me. I really felt like I was right there with them, laughing and joking and cooking fabulous food. They were a rag-tag bunch, but they really brought flavor and spice to the story.
As a side story, Miranda’s younger brother, Jesse, turns up from college (somewhere in the Midwest) saying he’s not going back. He gets a job at Market working as a server. As it turns out, he’s gay and falls in love with one of the sou chefs, Frankie, which Miranda hates. She thinks Frankie corrupted and tempted her poor straight brother into being gay.
I thought the story with the brother was cute, though I did struggle with his age quite a bit. He’s only 19. The problem is I wasn’t as bothered by that as I felt I should have been. Especially since Frankie is quite a bit older than him. Why is it that I’m willing to forgive a 19yo hero when he’s gay, but wouldn’t forgive a 19yo heroine (in a contemp) regardless? Once I got past that, though, I really enjoyed his part of the story.
So at this point in the book Miranda comes off as bitter, cynical and jaded. She’s also a complete control freak. Which is fine. I could have dealt with that if it had been one of the centerpieces of the story – how Miranda grew up. Unfortunately I didn’t find that to be the case.
Because at the end? She SAYS SHE LOVES HIM AND STILL SUBMITS THE FUCKING BOOK.
WHAT THE FUCK!?!?!?!?!
Her reason for doing so? She needs the money so she can pay for her brother to go to NYU. The problem? She only wants to pay for it to get him away from Frankie so he’ll go back to being “normal” instead of “gay”. Not only that, but he specifically told her he didn’t want her paying for his tuition. He said he wanted to be a responsible adult and contribute something himself. I understand that she wanted to help him as much as she could, but she SOLD OUT THE MAN SHE LOVED AND ALL HIS FRIENDS/EMPLOYEES to do it.
WHAT THE FUCK?!?!?!?!?!
And the best part? The only person she has to rely on and go to for support during this whole thing with her brother is Adam. She leans on him and lets him support her and SAYS SHE LOVES HIM AND THEN SELLS HIM OUT IN A CHEAP FUCKING BOOK!
WHAT THE FUCK?!?!?!?!?!
The thing is, I loved everything else about the book. The kitchen setting, the secondary characters, the hero. I even loved that the author included some of the recipes she used in the book (I’m sooo going to try them). I’m trying to decide if the heroine ruined the book for me, or if I can move past what she did. Right now I’d probably grade it:
3 out of 5 for the overall story, setting and characters
1 out of 5 for the heroine (maybe even a -1)
I did enjoy parts of it enough to want to read the next book in the series, On the Steamy Side, which will be available March, 2010.
This book is available from St. Martin’s. You can buy it here or here (I’m not including a link to buy in e-format b/c I think St. Martin’s has terrible e-pricing. The paperback is $6.99 but the e-book is $14. WTF St. Martin’s? W.T.F?).
Now I have to read this, just to see if I agree w/ you.
I saw all kinds of great reviews for this book and so got it myself. I know where you are coming from. There are so many delightful things about it – but I can’t stand the control freakishness of the heroine. She really gets on my nerves. And when I don’t like the heroine, it’s really hard to overcome that. I haven’t finished it and I started it a while ago. Now that’s not to say I won’t finish it – but I need a break from Miranda – not a good sign.
Oh no!! I have this in the mail to me right now.
Oh no. I have this in my TBR pile. I hate jaded back stabbing heroines. Ugh.
Thanks for the heads up Holly.
Oh no! (Deja vu?) I won a copy of this and it’s in the mail!
See, the control freak part I can understand, although I’d like to point out I just attempt to control me *grin* but as for the rest?
*heads desk*
Holly – may I suggest a lovely food-orientated novella that you might like…it’s one of my favourites: A Man for All Seasonings (Day Le Claire), which is part of Harlequin’s Christmas Treats anthology.
So I take it you didn’t like the heroine 😉
Same here. I must read this so I can see how I would react to all of this.
I haven’t read this one yet but who knows, I might like it. I’m weird like that. LOL Thanks for the review, and I’m a follower now, just found ur blog!
I didn’t love this book. In fact, I gave it away. The heroine was a deal breaker for me. 🙁
Ouch, I have this in my TBR pile. It looked like a fun book. I read the first few pages and the ending and so far, hadn’t had any other urges to pick it up ^_^;
Hey, that would be a great post: Foodie books.
I just read two but they were memoirs: Julie and Julia (loved it) and Hungry Woman in Paris (not quite as much, but had some redeeming features).
In novels, the one I enjoy liking a lot was a medieval by Betina Krahn, I think it was called the The Marriage Test. There is Delicious by Sherry Thomas (still in my TBR but I don’t doubt it’s fabulous) and there was one from Laura Lee Guhrke (Secrets of a Gentleman?) with a historical patissier heroine.
oh, and I was inspired to give my novel for NaNoWRiMo this year a foodie theme! Let’s see what happens with that
Yes, Delicious by Sherry Thomas is excellent! Also, you might try Miranda Neville’s Never Resist Temptation — the heroine is a French patisserie chef who dresses as a boy and gets hired by the hero. There are recipes between some chapters, and the decadence of the food is very sexy.
I would HATE that heroine What a bitch. I didn’t like her just from you talking about her how the hell would I read a whole book with her in it? But the rest of the book sounds charming. Too bad she ruined. And trying to make her brother “normal” ug. Don’t get me started. lol
Thanks for the review Holly!
Avoiding investigative journalists would deny you the best romantic suspense series out there – Pamela Clare’s I-Team series!!