Guest Review: Akata Witch by Nnedi Okorafor

Posted June 11, 2015 by Whitley B in Reviews | 0 Comments

9780670011964_p0_v1_s260x420Whitley’s review of Akata Witch by Nnedi Okorafor.

Twelve-year-old Sunny lives in Nigeria, but she was born American. Her features are African, but she’s albino. She’s a terrific athlete, but can’t go out into the sun to play soccer. There seems to be no place where she fits. And then she discovers something amazing—she is a “free agent,” with latent magical power. Soon she’s part of a quartet of magic students, studying the visible and invisible, learning to change reality. But will it be enough to help them when they are asked to catch a career criminal who knows magic too?

I wanted to like this one. I’d heard such good things about it, mostly about the originality and imagination. And…eh. There really wasn’t much to write home about. I mean, you can call your magic “juju,” but when it works the same way in the end, is it really different? I’ll grant you, there are a few clever ideas in here, but they end up being random scattered details, and nearly every book has that, so I’m not really seeing where all the hype came from. The framework is the same we’ve seen in a million other stories, and most of the original stuff doesn’t hang very well on it.

Basically, this is your “young person discovers there’s a world of magic and they’re part of this secret group of people living right under the mundanes’ noses and now they have to go and learn about their magical powers” story. Which, fine, it’s a good framework. It’s been used in a lot of stories, but there’s room to change enough of the set-dressing and still make it fun and entertaining. This…was not fun and entertaining. This was a lot of really random things hung willy-nilly on that familiar framework until it more resembled a ratty Christmas tree than a story. I never got any sense of cohesion from the setting we had. There was no larger whole. There were people, and they did magic, and sometimes they did magic in this one magic place, and…ooooh, look, something shiny. And then money falls out of the sky. Literally.

This could be the fault of the plot, which is literally “no one tells Sunny anything for 100 pages, followed by a bunch of random and completely unconnected magic lessons that do not add up to anything.” I guess it is hard to see much of the world when your characters are only wandering around on random, pointless tasks. For much of the story, magic wasn’t even really a big focus of the book. Hell, the biggest event that happened was a soccer game where magic was strictly forbidden. It made everything drag on interminably, until the final showdown with a villain who has had, like, 1% of presence in the novel before that. Really, in the final 50 pages or so, some people drag Sunny out of bed and say “hey, the bad guy is over there, go get him” and then shove her out the door. She didn’t have to do anything to lead up to this showdown, there was no build up, no rising action at all, just shoving the main character out the door and calling it a day.

By the way, let’s talk about that money that falls from the sky. In this book’s world, you get paid by money that just…appears. Ostensibly you get paid by…God, or whatever, when you learn something, but it’s not very clear what constitutes learning. Hell, the kids got paid for that damn soccer game somehow. You’re right, that doesn’t make sense. Also topping the charts in no-sense-making: how do you make an economy out of something that literally falls out of the sky? And which shows up for something that doesn’t even contribute to society! You can invent new magic, make magical charms and equipment, write magical books, build magical buildings…and some smug asshole hermit who sits around reading is going to be literally showered in coins instead. To top off the cake? The money eventually disappears back to where it came from. So smug asshole hermit can get free money from reading, pay a farmer for his food, and the farmer will have to…I guess just hope and pray that the coins don’t evaporate before his rent is due? There is nothing about this system that doesn’t scream intellectual elitism and it rubs me wrong in every conceivable way. (Starting with the fact that it’s not even smart and going all the way through to “wait, does that make me intellectually elite, too? Damn, no, I don’t want anything in common with this concept!”)

There were a lot of other things that irked me: the stilted writing, the lack of attention or history given to Sunny’s domestic problems, the fact that the sparse and distracted worldbuilding extended to the mundane Nigerian setting as well as the magical one, the plethora of random characters that just…take up space and then leave again. Most of this book was a cool idea, but unfortunately, most of this book didn’t get past the “cool idea” stage.

Rating: 2 out of 5

This title is available from Viking Children’s.  You can purchase it here or here in e-format.

Tagged: , , , , ,

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.